I'm really not sure what you are asking. Most have given the taller type shield the nod here, but I seem to think you are looking the other way.
V-Sream is good and what I am using, it is wide and a good replacement for stock. Adjustable and vented, seems to make the pillion happy, but a little too quiet a bubble for me. Not too much moving behind it, baker wings help cure that. Wind Bender makes an adjustable shield that looks a little shorter and presumably gives a bit more options for the rider. It has a following, but I can't really comment on it because I never used one.
Stock could be fine for you, but it buffets a bit for some folks.
Welcome to the Madd House.
Happy hunting.